1. News & Issues
You can opt-out at any time. Please refer to our privacy policy for contact information.

Immigration Issues: U.S.-Mexico Border Fence Pros and Cons

By

Border Security Unaffected By US Government Shutdown
John Moore/Getty Images News/Getty Images

We Need the Fence

Policing borders has been integral to the preservation of nations around the globe for centuries. The construction of a fence to safeguard American citizens from illegal activities is in the best interest of the nation.

Illegal immigration is estimated to cost the United States millions of dollars in lost income tax revenue. It also drains government spending by overburdening social welfare, health and education programs.

The use of physical barriers and high-tech surveillance equipment increases the probability of apprehension. The fences that are currently in place have shown success.

Arizona has been the epicenter for crossings by illegal immigrants for several years. Last year, authorities apprehended 8,600 people trying to enter the U.S. illegally in the Barry M. Goldwater Range.

The number of people caught crossing San Diego's border illegally has also dropped dramatically. In the early '90s, about 600,000 people attempted to cross the border illegally. After the construction of a fence and increased border patrols, that number dropped to just 153,000 in 2007.

The Fence Isn't the Answer

Many Americans feel that we should be sending a message of freedom and hope to those seeking a better way of life, instead of hanging a KEEP OUT sign on our borders' fences. They argue that the answer doesn't lie in barriers; it lies in comprehensive immigration reform. Until the foundation of our immigration issues are fixed, building fences is like putting a bandage on a gaping wound.

Environmentalists are particularly unhappy about the border fence. Physical barriers hinder migrating wildlife, and plans show the fence will fragment wildlife refuges and private sanctuaries. Conservation groups are appalled that the Department of Homeland Security is bypassing dozens of environmental and land-management laws in order to build the border fence. Among the 30-some laws being waived are the Endangered Species Act and the National Environmental Policy Act.

There is also the human aspect to consider. Fences increase the risk and costs of crossing. When risk increases, the people smugglers, called "coyotes," start to charge more for safe passage. When smuggling costs rise, it becomes less cost-effective for individuals to travel back and forth for seasonal work, so they must remain in the U.S. Now the whole family must make the trip to keep everyone together. Children, infants and the elderly will attempt to cross. The conditions are extreme, and people will go for days without food or water. According to U.S. Border Control, almost 2,000 people died crossing the border between 1998 and 2004.

Barriers won't stop people from wanting a better life. And in some cases, they're willing to pay the highest price for the opportunity.

Where It Stands

©2014 About.com. All rights reserved.